Skip to main content

mantaroof.com

Roof Restoration vs. Roof Replacement: When to Restore Instead of Tearing Off

Most low-slope commercial roofs that leak are not finished. If the deck is sound, a liquid-applied restoration system can rebuild the waterproofing over the existing roof, with no tear-off, no debris hauled to the landfill and no shutdown of the building below. This guide explains how to tell whether your roof is a restoration candidate, how a restoration is done properly and which system fits which roof. It is written by Manta Roofing Products, a manufacturer of silicone, acrylic, emulsion and spray foam roofing systems in La Verne, California and Fort Lauderdale, Florida, using what we see on our contractors’ roofs every week.

Restoration vs. replacement at a glance

Liquid-applied restorationTear-off and replacement
Existing roofStays in place and becomes the base of the new systemRemoved down to the deck and hauled away
Building operationsNormally continue during the workInterior exposed while the roof is open
SeamsNone; the coating forms one monolithic membraneSheet membranes are welded, taped or torched at every seam
DetailsCoating flows around pipes, curbs and equipmentEach penetration is flashed piece by piece
End of service lifeClean, repair and recoatAnother tear-off
Warranty (Manta)10, 15 or 20 years through a Certified Manta ApplicatorDepends on the membrane manufacturer

Restoration example

Is your roof a restoration candidate?

A restoration needs a sound structure to bond to. In practice, contractors check four things before they quote a restoration:

  • The deck is sound. Rotted or failed deck areas have to be repaired or rebuilt first. As long as the deck is sound, very rough roofs can be restored, including gravel roofs, roofs with old aluminum coatings and roofs crowded with HVAC equipment.
  • Trapped moisture is found and removed. A moisture scan identifies wet insulation. Wet areas are cut out and replaced so the roof is dry before it is sealed in.
  • The coating will bond. Adhesion tests on the actual roof confirm which primer the surface needs before the full job is bought.
  • Water can drain. Low areas and voids can be built up with spray foam before coating so the finished roof drains.

How a proper roof restoration is done

  1. Clean. The roof is pressure-washed to remove dirt and contaminants that would weaken the bond.
  2. Test and scan. Adhesion tests and a moisture scan, as above.
  3. Repair and detail. Wet areas are replaced, seams, flashings and penetrations are sealed with repair mastics such as MantaFlash™ 330 for silicone systems or MantaHybrid™ 318 for acrylic systems, and low areas are filled.
  4. Prime. The primer is matched to the surface: a bleed blocker over asphalt, a multipurpose primer over metal, single-ply, concrete or old aluminum coatings. See the MantaPrime™ primer line.
  5. Coat. The top coat is applied at the specified rate for the warranty, by spray or roller, and on many silicone roofs broadcast with granules for added durability.
MantaSPF™ InstaShield 250 foam reinforcing roof penetrations and supports before silicone
Spray foam reinforcing penetrations and supports on a 70,000 sq ft roof before the bleed blocker and silicone top coat.

Which system fits your roof

Silicone system

MantaPrime™ 230 Bleed Block Primer followed by MantaSil™ 430 high-solids silicone. Silicone is the choice when the roof holds water after rain, and it can be broadcast with granules on roofs that see foot traffic. MantaSil™ 430 is CRRC rated (initial solar reflectance 0.87, SRI 110).

Reinforced emulsion and acrylic system

Manta asphalt emulsion embedded with polyester reinforcement, topped with MantaCryl™ 410 or MantaCryl™ 415 acrylic. The reinforced base seals and reinforces every flashing, pipe and skylight and can encapsulate an old gravel surface. This type of system has been used on low-slope roofs for decades.

Hybrid emulsion and silicone system

The same reinforced emulsion base, then MantaPrime™ 230 to lock down the asphalt and keep the finish white, then MantaSil™ 430.

When the roof needs more than a coating: rebuild it in place with spray foam

If the roof needs more than a coating, MantaSPF™ spray foam rebuilds it in place, with no tear-off. The foam is sprayed over the existing roof, adds insulation, can rebuild slope to drains and is coated with MantaSil™ 430 or MantaCryl™ 410. On a 150,000 sq ft manufacturing roof, this let the plant keep running through the job.

Drone view of a formerly leaking roof restored with MantaSil™ 430 two days before a storm
A leaking commercial roof restored with MantaPrime™ 230 and MantaSil™ 430, finished just before a major storm.

Why owners choose restoration

  • No tear-off waste. The existing roof stays on the building instead of going to the landfill.
  • Less disruption. The building stays covered and in use; tenants and operations are not exposed.
  • A renewable roof. At the end of the warranty, the roof can be cleaned, inspected and recoated instead of replaced.
  • A cooler roof. White and light-colored coatings reflect sunlight; Manta’s white coatings are rated by the Cool Roof Rating Council.
  • A warranty. Manta restoration systems carry 10, 15 or 20-year warranties. Every Manta warranty includes MantaCare, Manta’s maintenance program. See the warranty program.

See finished roofs and the systems used on them in our roof restoration projects, and compare coating types on our roof coatings page.

Frequently asked questions

Can a roof with leaks be restored?

Yes, if the deck is sound. Leaks are repaired and wet insulation is replaced before the system is applied. Many of the projects in our gallery had active leaks before restoration.

Can you coat over a gravel roof?

Yes. The gravel can be leveled and encapsulated in a polyester-reinforced emulsion base, then top coated with acrylic.

Can you restore a roof that has an old aluminum coating?

Yes, with the right primers. On a high-rise assisted living facility, a multipurpose primer and a bleed blocker were applied over the aluminum coating before MantaSil™ 430.

How long does a restored roof last?

Manta warranties run 10, 15 or 20 years depending on the system and the coating thickness specified. At the end of that period, the roof can be cleaned and recoated.

Who can install a warranted Manta system?

Only a Certified Manta Applicator. Find your Manta rep to be connected with one.